This was an experiment I conducted in 2011. I wanted to see what happened to Pinot Noir if we restricted precipitation ingress through the period veraison -3 weeks. We could detach the covers, and allow some rainfall to hit the ground, but it didn't rain.
We lifted the covers after veraison, and still it didn't rain.
No rain until harvest, in fact.
Saturday, 8 December 2012
Thursday, 6 December 2012
Pétrus: a postsript
Back in 1990 I
was a customer of Pétrus. I bought 24 bottles of 1989 en primeur, and sold them when the price doubled to £1000 per case,
cannily entering the market before the Bordeaux bubble burst; only it never
did. At around the same time I visited
the Château. After a short tour, my colleague was asked his birth year, and was
either honest or stupid enough to reply “1967”.
A magnum of 1967 was summarily opened. I have drunk 64, 67, 70, 71, 82,
85, 88(twice), 90, 95, but the 67 remains the most memorable. What that says
about me, storage, vintage, format and terroir
I haven’t fully worked out yet.
Twenty
years later I returned to Pétrus, this time by bus. The Domaine had immodestly
bolstered its fortifications. Like an Edgware “semi” whose owners think
erecting 2 tons of ornamental railings somehow re-configures their house as a palace,
the old maison of Pétrus just seemed
diminished by its new wrought iron defences. There’s an obvious need to keep
unwanted visitors out (somebody from our bus was trying to get through the
gates in a tangerine Wolves strip),
but you would feel pretty foolish if you’d travelled across the World on a
pilgrimage to Bordeaux, only to spend your time viewing the top châteaux off
the tarmac. I know this because I was on the road with a group of angry Texans,
who up to that point had roamed through the region’s petits châteaux drunk and unimpeded. Exclusion hadn’t figured in
their plans, as it hadn’t mine. Since my last visit I’d become an MW and
written a few scholarly papers on marketing, Burgundy and terroir. Wine related employment had at long last shoved holiday
jobs, platitudes and lies off the bottom of my résumé; yet despite all my
attempts to turn this short list of achievements into a persuasive case for
entry, I couldn’t get through the gates of Pétrus for a second time. Schmucks
like me and the Wolves fan needed to
find satisfaction in life’s lesser extravagances, like air-conditioned coaches,
on board toilet facilities and window seats.
My
psycho-analyst wife told me (in a tone that sounded like a threat) that after
divorce, one partner normally does well whilst the other struggles. Pétrus’s
fortunes were clearly in the ascendancy, and mine had taken a dive. Once the
Belgians had the Domaine to themselves; now the rest of the World was at the
party. Pétrus has become a global signifier of good taste, and demonstrating
this level of discrimination and discernment was never going to be cheap; too
many buyers, and one seller: prices went north, and the wines went West, then
East.
Good
taste is enduring, built upon myths of perfection and imperishability, whereas
the merely fashionable is transient. It’s hard to think of a future in which
we’d say of Picasso’s les Demoiselles
d’Avignon “It has had its day”. By contrast, the orange-and-blue-check
Kenzo trousers I bought as a student had already had their moment when I
resuscitated them off the £5 rail. Worn around college they singled me out as a
guy with poor dress-sense and short legs. The durability of taste is bound-up
with the imperishability of its objects, and the persistence of our desire for
them.
Similarly,
Bordeaux’s reputation is founded on its long-lived Crus Classés; in fact, a
disproportionate part of the wine business seems dedicated to representing and
projecting this particular dimension of clarets’ personality. In his excellent
book “The Billionaire’s Vinegar”, Benjamin Wallace accuses the fine wine
establishment of hubris. In a memorable passage, Wallace reports a Rodenstock
tasting where the moderating Michael Broadbent MW dismisses one taster’s
scepticism of what turned out to be blends of dud 60s vintages as inexperience
with pre-phylloxera clarets. Wallace relentlessly depicts Broadbent as a posh
spiv intent on blurring the boundaries between hauteur mercantilism and
expertise.
Broadbent
sued Random House for deformation and won, though the moratorium on the books
publication only applied to the UK. The Rodenstock affair reminded us that wine
is mortal. Nineteen forty-seven Cheval Blanc will never be the liquescent
equivalent of Seurat’s sublime study of infinite perspective le Port de Gravelines, because wines’
chemistry is fundamentally unstable, and its pleasures perishable, albeit it an
interesting way.
Those
who have had a dog die on them know it’s a tough call. On the way to the vets
you’re looking for those vital signs - a wet nose, a wagging tail, licks -
which mean you can turn the car round. Tasting old wines is pretty much the
same thing. I have attended confréries when some very old wines have been
poured; and I would be honoured if Michael Broadbent chastised me for being
“green” in the presence of pre-phylloxera bottles, because I have only ever
drunk one: Lafite 1858. Afterwards I wrote of the wine: “We eulogised it; gave
it a wake; and were careful not to say it was long-dead”. Just like an old dog
kept alive for too long, we urge knackered old wines onwards into ever more
decrepit futures. Wallace beat-up Broadbent because he was pompous, but like
most of us he just proved fallible when faced with yet more evidence of the
mortality of things. Not once in those confrérie tastings did anybody stand up
and say this wine is finished, even though we often read it in each other’s
eyes.
One
consequence of Pétrus inflation is that I drink less of it. The last bottle I
drank was 1988, which was mine; unmistakeably mine as I’d ripped the label and
botched its value. Today’s Pétrus owners are a disparate international bunch,
often separated from their bonded cases by thousands of miles or on-going court
proceedings, so I suspect the trend for less rather than more Pétrus in my life
is set to continue. On the radio the other day I listened to a programme about
Gaelic dialects dying out. Less than 100,000 speakers, and a language risks
terminal decline; on this basis, I just wonder how many people in the future
will have drunk enough vintages of Pétrus to pass meaningful judgements upon
it. The fate of Pétrus might be like that of pre-phylloxera clarets where all
the intellectual property became tied-up with too few people, and we know how that story ended-up. With this in mind, perhaps now is the right time for me to
pass my verdict on Pétrus, based upon the limited number of vintages I have
tasted, which is, perhaps, more than you. It’s certainly more than those I met
outside the Château’s gates in 2009. Consequently, I am dedicating the
remainder of this text to the drunken Texans and the Wolves supporter who in his tangerine football strip reminded me of
one of those tropical birds cruelly carried away from its familiar habitat by a
freak storm.
The
first thing to say is that Pétrus is a serious wine; a little melancholic
even; and it doesn’t always show well against other top growths – unlike
Haut-Brion, say. Instead, it lurks in the shadows, and when every other wine
has contributed it’s all to the evening’s merriment, it’s still there,
brooding, like Mr Darcy in a glass. I once served the 1988 to friends, together
with Vieux Château Certan 98. I’d bought a case of the Vieux Château Certan 98,
and just one bottle of the Pétrus. Through the evening, everyone agreed that the
Vieux Château Certan was much the better wine, and such great value in
comparison; it was joyous, and just seemed to donate every last drop of itself
towards the purposes of our pleasure. When all our guests had left, I cleaned
up the kitchen, except for a pair of glasses that held a fraction of each wine.
The Vieux Château Certan seemed spent (we really couldn’t have asked any more
of it), but that damned meniscus of Pétrus, the wine I had underestimated to my
cost before, was still smouldering away; resolutely knocking its point home;
filling me with doubt.
And
what does Pétrus taste of? Like wine; like Bordeaux; like Pomerol, really -
though there is a difference. Fundamentally, it’s the same stuff: merlot, oak,
plums, silk, and sweetness; the silty-scent of time’s passage; yet the elements
appear bonded together into a unique configuration, as if to create a bolder
and more robust allotrope of Pomerol; and it’s this statuesque quality that
makes Pétrus such an enigma to me. Before the Rodenstock affair I thought all
wine was mortal, whilst afterwards I knew it was; except it feels like nobody
told the people at Pétrus that the game was up. In Disney’s telling of
Cinderella, everything starts reverting back at midnight: the coach becomes a
pumpkin again, and the fat mouse is back in his rags; but the slipper carries
on, keeping the story alive. The palace ball is a preamble. Patience is
rewarded: The Prince gets his princess, just as Mr Darcy turns out to be the
good guy; and an hour after our dinner guests had left that night, I quietly
admitted to myself, in a dark corner, that the 88 Pétrus was the better wine.
Psychoanalysts,
my wife included, will tell you that the best stories don’t so much frustrate
desire, as postpone satisfaction. The 67 Petrus I drank in Pomerol was the most
compelling wine I have tasted from the Estate, because at 23 years of age it
was ready to drink. If you are born in 1967, then the normal wine trade
practice is to age yourself by a year, and make your hosts open a 66. But believe
me you don’t need to do this at Pétrus , if you ever get in, that is.
Pétrus
may stoke the embers of old wine trade tales about wine immortality, but it
also slays one particular myth that has been doing the rounds for far too
long. I was always told Bordeaux’s best
vineyards have deep roots, which somehow access a hidden trove of deeply buried
minerals. The soil at Pétrus is predominantly clay, but incorporated into the
clay is smectite, a volcanic mineral, that dramatically changes the soil’s
physical and chemical properties. Conditions within damp smectite clays are so
anaerobic that new roots struggle to grow, while old roots die. Consequently,
the vines struggle to extract water from the soil despite the fact the clay
feels wet to the touch. The expansion is so dramatic that after 10mm of rain,
the soil self-seals at its surface, so in wet year like 1967, the vines can
still be subjected to beneficial levels of water stress. Conversely in dry
years, smectite clays shrink, and crack, encouraging water and root
penetration, which in turn, maintain a restricted but valuable flow of
nutrients and water to the vine. This is terroir,
for those who were beginning to see it everywhere they looked.
Pétrus
is, then, both icon and iconoclasm. It is the exemplar of terroir, and deserves distinction; but at what cost? For most
drinkers the wine has effectively become priceless, and they’ve been out the
game for a long time, which is disappointing. We sometimes need to catch a
resemblance of a region’s best wines in more affordable bottles, so we can
appreciate their qualities better. This inflation in value has made fortunes
for some, and ruined the reputations of others, making the English wine trade
look like a school for scoundrels at
the same time. It was large Pétrus formats that finally exposed Rodenstock’s
fraud, when Moueix audited their records and found they hadn’t made Imperials
in the 1921 and 1928 vintages; though Rodenstock’s fraud now looks
insignificant next to recent revelations of Asian warehouses full of
counterfeit bottles. The prospect of spending fortunes on bottles and them not
being authentic is very real; not that this will bother everyone. The only time
I tried 1982 Pétrus, was after I’d listed it at a smart London hotel restaurant.
A woman came into the restaurant alone. She ordered à la carte, and then picked
a bottle each of Krug Rosé and Pétrus 82 off the wine list. She took a sip of
both wines, paid the bill and left. We were all bemused, until the receptionist
worked out that her husband was staying in the hotel that night, but he wasn’t
alone, and he wasn’t with her. Ouch!
Monday, 19 November 2012
Which tasting notes will help my red wine age?
On passing the MW you are required
to participate in the Institute’s education programme, and as part of this obligation
I spent several days marking students tasting notes. The best notes were
deductive - the Institute has an exacting approach to notation – whilst the
worst answers just kept on plundering a limited lexicon of descriptions, like a
still-life artist condemned to rearranging and painting the same bowl of fruit
over and over and over again.
Subjecting nouns to this sort
of functional and metaphorical shift in usage is meat and drink to the wine trade.
Anyone who has ever stood-up in front of a crowd of diners with a glass of wine
in hand knows nothing pacifies a drunken mob better than the timely naming of a
fruit: “raspberries here”, “plums”, “blackcurrants” etc , and it’s tempting to
think the better the wine the more elaborate and more exotic these depictions must
be. Yet it seems that just as you can induce a trance by staring into a mirror
for too long, so continually hanging your nose over the same wine will
eventually bring-on olfactory hallucinations. How else can we possibly account
for people conjuring up such queasy mixes as cassis, cherries, bacon-fat,
Asian-spices, pepper, liquorice and garrigue within one glass? And at what
point does wine tasting become legalised solvent abuse?
Often tagged onto these
longer notes are “drinking windows”, and it’s not unusual to find that there is
a correspondence between the over-endowment of descriptors and the number of years
to peak maturity. Discursiveness and ageing potential seem inextricably
linked. You think its complex now,
blah, blah, blah, Asian spices, blah? Well, you ain’t seen nothing yet! 2025-blah.
Somewhat against the trend,
I am increasingly persuaded that ageing potential follows on from wines’
homogeneity rather than the faux-complexity found by over-zealous tasters. In
my recent blog on Otago (The Heart of Lightness) I drew out the differences as
I saw them between Otago and the Cote de Nuits:
"Depending on your
point of view, a prism either scatters light into its constituent wavelengths
or refocuses them back into a single beam. Loosely applied, this seems a
reasonable analogy for the differences I tasted between the Pinot Noir of
Felton Rd and the wines of Vosne Romanée; viticulture, vinification, elevage,
maturation, and polymerisation act like a lens in Burgundy, drawing everything
to a point, whereas at Felton Rd, the studied application of the same
techniques produces a hugely varied palate."
If you taste red burgundy whilst
feigning ignorance of its appellation divisions, then the wines can be
categorized according to the purity and intensity of the rather singular red
fruit character they possess, and the extent to which the rustic counterpoint
to this fruitiness is replaced by condensed and soluble tannins. In other words,
the trend towards homogenisation is a good sign in young red burgundy. In fact,
I would go as far as to say that the ageing potential for Pinot Noir is
inseparable from this process of youthful coalescence.
And why stop with Burgundy.
The best wines of Pomerol can have a lozenge-like softness. I recently wrote of
Vieux Chateau Certan it was “Blissfully simple”, which might sound like I was
damning the wine with faint praise, when in fact I was utterly entranced.
Richard Smart taught us that
deep shade is the enemy of high quality wine production, and since he first
published “Sunlight into Wine” we have been slowly learning about the
intricacies of the relationship between light exposure and wine style. At first, sunlight exposure and long hang-times
sounded like good prescriptions in cool and temperate climates, yet the more I
taste and compare wines drawn from different hemispheres and continents, the
more convinced I am that long exposure to direct and diffuse UV builds flavour at
the expense of homogeneity. Chilean Pinot might taste of blackberries,
cherries, rhubarb, coffee, ivy and resin, but it’s hard to work out how wines
inclined towards such youthful divergence will do anything other than fracture further
apart with age. Far from being the prerequisite for ageing, youthful complexity
perhaps mitigates against anything but future decline.
Monday, 12 November 2012
Otago: The Heart of Lightness
The flight from London to New Zealand is the closest I will
ever come to intergalactic travel. On my last trip I stayed for 4 days. After a
weekend in the air, the plane touched down in Queenstown late on a Sunday
afternoon. Saturday had been lost, light turned into darkness, 24hrs whittled
down into a quick bowl of soy-drenched noodles in Hong Kong.
At the airport urinals, flanked by two giant Polynesians, the
three of us pressed together like the pipes of a church organ, I pondered Darwin’s
observation that evolution encourages diversity rather than dominance, and that
Nature likes a niche, and one size really doesn’t fit all. I wasn’t built for
oceanic migrations, they weren’t built for airline seats, and all three of us
were too tall to dock effectively with the low-slung porcelain bowls in front
of us. The man to the right of me seemed intent on making a particularly personal
statement about the shortcomings of standardisation by recklessly hosing my
hand-luggage. The horror!
Queenstown offers geography in the raw: mountains, lakes, rivers,
lenticular clouds and adrenaline-filled rides between them; but most
importantly, it held out the prospect of sleep. I rolled into bed at 10pm, only
to find that the Boeing’s west-to-east navigation had wedged a void of
space-time between me and unconsciousness. I switched on the AM radio, and caught
the tail-end of some irate exchanges about the Chinese taking Kiwi jobs, and rallying
calls to resist the New World order of slave cities and poorly made white goods.
Calm was restored by a record break, Allan Sherman’s ”Hello Muddah, Hello Faddah” followed by “Big John”. The combination of moribund songs and fury was reminiscent of my childhood. the scene was set for 70s punk to explode into these angry famers' 21st Century lives.
The following day I drove out to Cromwell, past Chard Farm and
through Gibbston Valley. The day’s first visit was Mt Difficulty, where all the
money seemed to have been spent on the smart new canteen. I tried a few uncared
for bottles, ullaged by out of season visitors, but the guy pouring them still seemed
zombified by summer’s mass influx of tasters. When I asked him about oak
handling, he replied that “the wine showed good fruit”; and he reacted to my
question about “malo” by pointing me toward the male loos.
Next-door to Mt. Difficulty is Felton Road, where I was
greeted by the expansive Nigel Greening. Immediately Nigel started referencing France
and Germany, making anecdotal associations between his vineyards and the finest
terroirs of Vosne and the Mosel. One
of his pets, I soon found out, was called “Jancis”. Minimizing degrees of separation
seemed to be at the bottom of nearly everything Nigel said, and after half an
hour I concluded that all Europe had contributed to the making of Felton Road
in one way or another.
Vineyards at Felton Rd are called “blocks”. At Mt Difficulty
the viticulture had been slapdash, whereas the “blocks” were immaculate: shoots
of even length and even vigour carrying similar amounts of crop. Nigel went
into considerable detail about biodynamic production: goats, hawks, cover
crops, preps; yet, as ever, the whole reasoned panoply of self-contained
production seemed at odds with the accompanying
anti-enlightenment yarns about totemic animals. The conversation went from a
reasoned and visible account of the workings of an enclosed agricultural system
to absurd anthroposophical flights of fancy. The goats were doing a good
recycling job, that much I could see, but by the time Nigel had finished I was prepared
for a bleating chorus of Odl-lay odl-lay odl-lay hoo! hoo!
Despite
all of Nigel’s attempts to lock them together like the north and south poles
of a magnet, Otago isn’t Burgundy. The first wine we tried was a Chardonnay.
Someone whose name meant nothing to me had likened this to “Montrachet” I was
told, but it wasn’t. Wild fermentation had supplemented the simple citrus nose
with flavours of yeast and barley. It was a good wine, quite acidulous, and a fitting reward for all the hours
spent in the vineyards. Next we had a
pair of Pinot Noirs, Felton Rd Estate
and Block 5. Nigel got into his
stride about how they had identified thin seams of calcareous gravel within the
schist, and the roots had threaded along these, so despite the fact Bannockburn’s
geology seemed very different from the Côte de Nuits, the cameo appearance of
marl had contrived to make them twins of a sort. As I tasted the wines, Nigel
reiterated the cross-hemispherical connection with an anecdote about draught
horses ploughing la Tâche, but my memories of hideously
extended air travel were all too raw for this.
Otago is cooler and drier than Burgundy, it’s also geologically
younger. At the height of summer the bleached karst scenery of the
Côte d’Or can evoke the Midi, whilst Otago in February still looks periglacial,
with fast moving streams icily under lit by refracted blue/green light. But
stepping out into the late “Central” summer the most striking contrast is not
the landscape but the luminance; New Zealand’s sun seems nearer and hotter,
like the encroaching star of an apocalyptic sci-fi novel.
“Sunlight into Wine” was one of the seminal texts of my MW
studies, and inevitably it influenced my tasting of Felton’s Pinot Noir. Not
only is irradiance 40% higher in Otago than it is in Burgundy, but the lateness
of the harvest means bunches hang in the sunlight for longer. What struck me
about both the Felton Rd and Block 5 was the range of flavours; there
were black fruits, red fruits, rhubarb, citrus, ivy, oak and spice; in fact, if
wine quality was measured by the lexicon of descriptors a single variety could
inspire, then Otago Pinot would be slugging it out with Californian Zinfandel
and Barossa Shiraz for best in show. The contrast with the Côte de Nuits could not be greater. The finest red burgundies show
homogeneity in fruit character, their flavours pretty much tow in the same
direction and the attribution of quality is in part a measure of the intensity
this red fruit element attains; the lasting impression is something like a perfectly
sustained piano note, rather than a damped chord. By contrast, the Block 5 separated into a range of different
flavours, a melange of tart, ripe, overripe and spicy characters that were all vying
for my attention.
Depending on your point of view, a prism either scatters
light into its constituent wavelengths or refocuses them back into a single
beam. Loosely applied, this seems a reasonable analogy for the differences I tasted
between the Pinot Noir of Felton Rd and the wines of Vosne Romanée; viticulture, vinification, elevage, maturation, and polymerisation
act like a lens in Burgundy, drawing everything to a point, whereas at Felton Rd,
the studied application of the same techniques produces a hugely varied palate.
After Felton Road, I called in at Burn Cottage. Where Nigel
had managed to make biodynamics sound like la
dolce vita, Jarryd Connelly played out the role of the ascetic priest:
filthy finger nails, crumpled, his hands buried up to the elbows in preps, he was
some of Kurt Vonnegut’s mud that happened to sit-up. When I first met Jarryd he
was hand-weeding 60,000 vines, though he subsequently sent me an e:mail asking
my thoughts on the potential benefits of weed stress on young vines (There are
none.) The wines are made by Claire
Mulholland and Ted Lemon, a formidable team, and the first vintage of their
Pinot was more subtle than Felton Road’s, though I’m not sure subtlety is what
one should necessarily expect or even strive for in Otago.
Wanaka is more humid than Cromwell, and its rainfall totals
are not dissimilar to Burgundy’s, but the high irradiance levels still rip moisture
out of the soil faster than it can be replenished. Rippon Vineyard borders Lake Wanaka, and the views to Mt Cook arguably make
it the World’s most photogenic vineyard, but don’t be fooled into thinking this idyll
is incapable of doing useful work.
Nick Mills took over Rippon from his pioneering father. Nick worked
a few vintages in Burgundy, and spent long enough at DRC to tell me their viticulture
wasn’t the best he’d seen, though the wines were
something else. Nick wasn’t unctuous; he was spare with his commentary. He gauges how much he needs to tell you from the rigour of your questioning.
Like Burn Cottage and Felton Rd, Rippon is biodynamic, and as part of the tour I
was taken to the estate’s fermenting compost piles; in fact, we spent 40 minutes
with the compost, which made me think that Nick was deliberately trying to
break the spell of the vista. Compost is essential to Rippon, not least because
Nick dry farms the older vineyards. Pinot Noir seems to show at its best when
the supply of water and nutrients is uninterrupted, and the magnitude of the
compost piles proved this balance was hard earned.
Rippon’s Pinot Noir did seem more homogeneous than Felton Rd’s:
it was softer and less exotic; but the preference for one estate over the other
is a matter of individual taste. I liked Nick a lot too. At the end 16,000 miles of travel you need to
be inspired, because you’re a wreck, and Nick did this. After 3 hours at
Rippon, I got back into my car, returned to Queenstown and did what I had
wanted to do for the previous 3 days, slept until morning.
Saturday, 13 October 2012
MW Students of the World Unite
I think it’s about time you
organised a student revolt. One of the frustrations with the MW when I took it
was that in the absence of anybody being confident about teaching the “content” of the theory papers, the
institute obsessed with “schema”. This
seems to have become worse. The dissertation in becoming a “proxy MA”, is in
danger of testing methodological competence at the expense of commercial, viticultural
and enological interest, in the same way that MAs only really exist to get you
into good habits before you’re let loose on more meaningful research. The MW is
not a proving ground for PHDs and Post-Docs, but it does rely upon a lot of
hard work from examiners and mentors, and I just wonder what is in it for them
if the dissertations and study yield such barren and piecemeal conclusions.
Tuesday, 9 October 2012
Once a Master of Wine, always................
Bernard Schoffit was the first winemaker I chaperoned around London. Bernard turned out to be an an exemplary Alsacean: he looked like an athletic lover and, if needed, could wrestle a bear to the ground. He was a judo black belt, a force of nature, with an appetite to match; one night in Colmar, he ordered so much Vendange Tardive Pinot Gris and choucroute I woke up with moobs, and for a short while afterwards became completely intolerant of any kind of meat, fruit or vegetables.
Two months later, Bernard came to London. We spent the day enthusiastically introducing his Domaine to journalists and restaurateurs, but every time I got a whiff of his Vendange Tardive Pinot Gris I came over all queasy, the potency of involuntary memory pinging me back to Colmar’s bloating pigfest. Bernard was sickening too. For ten hours he manfully struggled with our language whilst stubbornly refusing our hospitality and food. The aura of constant hunger and lust that surrounded him in the Vosges had become tarnished by his day in the City. Like Elliot when he found ET floundering in the drain, I felt an overwhelming need to get my fading guest “home”.
That evening, as an aperitif, I had lined-up a range of Australian wines for Bernard to taste. With its umlauts and spired-bottles, Alsace is a winemaking backwater, so I thought I’d give Bernard his first opportunity to try Clare Shiraz, Margaret River Cabernet and Hunter Semillon. We would then go for a curry, another novelty, as Colmar didn’t even have a kebab house, and lamb jalfrezi sounded mercifully pork and cabbage-free to me.
We drank some good wines: an old Magill Shiraz, Cullen Cabernet/Merlot, Tyrell’s Hunter “Riesling” and Grange. I waited for the epiphany, the shot of fruity L-DOPA that would free Bernard from all the volkgeist and chauvinisme that until that moment had “France” fulfilling every one of his vinous needs. But our tasting passed without acclaim or enthusiasm: “Fruit juice, not wine”, was his withering appraisal. The ten year-old Grange got the highest accolade of the night: “Pas mal”. The curry didn’t fare any better. Perhaps Bernard was put-off by the novelty colours and the refracting film of cohesive-ghee that made tiny atolls out of his coral-dyed chicken; or maybe he thought that the dented stainless-steel dishes had once trafficked excised organs to the hospital furnaces. Either way, Bernard hardly touched his food. It was as if he was trying to protect his own rarefied sense of gewürz (spicy) from the thuggish assault of masala-sauce and the garnet meat of the kheema naan. The hot white towel could not have come soon enough: a steaming flag of surrender, hastily unfurled.
During the 1980s, the emergence of California, Australia and Chile as wine producing nations had flung open the doors of wine consumption, and I’d charged through. For me, France no longer owned “wine” in the same way it had done for previous generations. For all Bernard’s dawn’til dusk encounters with vines, I felt that I was more open-minded and better informed than him. Alsace is, after all, geographically isolated from the rest of France. At the same time, Robert Parker seemed to be having similar sorts of arguments over his 100 point scoring system, which offered a degree of equivalence between regions and continents.
This unequivocal attitude got me through the Master of Wine examination. Identifying 36 unknown wines requires that you ditch the aesthetic for the ascetic. You can’t spend precious exam time atomically splitting Meursault and Puligny, and they don’t hand-out marks for genuflection no matter how good the Monte Bello tasted. I wanted “bankers”, easily recognisable wines: Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc, Crozes-Hermitage and, if it came to it, Vendange Tardive Pinot Gris, as long as I got that wave of identifying nausea when I nosed the liquid. The only wine that fazed me in the exam was Cos d’Estournel 1990, which caused an inappropriate rush of excitement, the stirring of something deeply repressed, like those bewildering endocrinal pangs that must come to wild animals that are born in zoos. Five vintages of Cos correctly identified. The red wine paper was a triumph. Something in the genes my mum said; our pre-historic ancestors must have smelt terrible to each other, I thought.
There is an inevitable period of re-tox after the exam. I went to work in Champagne, off to the blurry world of blends and brands. It seemed an opt-out from all those choices the exam presented me with, but like a fervent Buddhist I found something enlightening in this singularity.
Blends are the nemesis of blind tasting. It’s hard enough remembering all those grape varieties, let alone their possible combinations, and in Champagne the mix of grape varieties, villages and years is endless. I was well practised in deciding between continents, so when I was given 10 Montagne de Reims vin clair to taste, my palate went numb. They were all Pinot Noir, and all from Champagne, two facts that together negated any contribution I could bring to the on-going blending discussion. In pursuit of the MW, I had visited New Zealand, Chile and Australia. I had offered unsolicited advice to Chilean winemakers, warning them of the dangers of reduction; and told one of New Zealand’s top Pinot Noir producers to replant his vineyards. Before I took the exam these put upon souls must have been sticking pins into “John” effigies, but the voodoo either didn’t work or veered into the examinee next to me whose glasses all smashed to the ground, spilling the Cos. By contrast, our cellar master rarely left Champagne. Verzenay, Oger and Bouzy marked the limits of his world. His authority was necessarily circumspect. We were both in the business of authenticating identity, except he was working with finger prints where I was making do with the Bumper Book of Flags.
When you bake bread you don’t want to overdo the eggs and butter, or else your baps might turn into scones. Similarly, the tirage is not a post-harvest potlatch into which you empty everything that’s in the cupboards. Like electro-magnetism, certain elements attract each other, whilst others repel. Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of this blending process is the fact that it’s a preamble to a second fermentation. In Bordeaux, blends between Merlot and Cabernet are pretty much stabilised before they go into bottle, whilst young Champagne is charged with yeast and sugar, primed for its next round of tumultuous reactions, and then crown-capped.
The prise de mousse brings amplification in character and style. Full-bodied wines will end-up lumbering, and blends that are tired at the outset will taste oxidised. Your starting point necessarily dictates the character of the finished wine. Get it right, and you boost the intensity and flavour of the wine, but not necessarily its vinosity.
Studying these neglected facts of Champagne’s production closely, I came to realise that the region has a strong qualitative connection with the rest of France. In particular, there exist a range of minerally-salty flavours that not only dominate Champagne, but also underscore the wines of the Loire, Burgundy and the Haut Medoc. (Think of the difference between Badoit and tap water.) At times this seasoning can seem overdone, its bitter element can reinforce unripe phenolic characters, particularly when acids are high, but in the Grands Crus of Burgundy and the Crus Classes of Bordeaux this mineral element not only adds flavour, but it enhances and fortifies the other tastes of the wine too.
Two things came out of this appreciation: firstly, that the Echelle system pretty much measures the intensity of this mineral element, and relates it back to chalk; and secondly, that throughout my MW tastings this particular property, shared by some of France’s finest wines, had eluded me. It needed a long and myopic encounter between me and Champagne to reveal itself.
These thoughts take me back to Bernard, and the lack of appreciation he showed for the trousseau of Australian wines we tasted before the disastrous curry. Bernard was prejudiced precisely because his experience of global wine production was so limited. He judged the wines by what they lacked, whilst I was busily enthusing about what they had. One of the real challenges of the MW exam is to shed yourself of preconceptions. I often thought that the lack of regular exposure to Crus Classes and Grands Crus might disadvantage me in the exam, but it probably meant I was usefully impartial to what was in my glass, which is the prerequisite for success in blind tasting.
Thirteen years on from passing the MW, the once wide-open doors of the New World are now almost completely closed to me. Only Ridge slips through with any regularity. Like Bernard, I am hopelessly neurotic in my wine preferences, and France pretty much has the run of our house: Chablis and Champagne in the summer, and Chambolle from autumn to spring. Once you start drinking wines from above 47 degrees north, you stop flying south for the winter. It is difficult to imagine a wine exam that could be harder than the MW, the gradients at times seem impossibly steep, but like climbing any ladder, the real revelations come when you finally get to kick the rungs away.
Saturday, 29 September 2012
Is this the problem with 2005 Red Burgundy?
Figure 1 Water deficits in mm: 2009vs2005vslongterm trend. Cote de Nuits
Below (Angleterroir? post) I drew
attention to the water requirements of anisohydric grape varierties – pinot noir,
syrah, merlot – and the fact that in non-irrigated regions they can be acutely sensitive
to droughts, whereas isohydric vines – cabernet sauvignon, grenache - can better regulate and maintain vine water
status through control of leaf stomatal aperture. We might extrapolate from this that in Bordeaux,
cabernet has a greater overall affinity with the region's rapidly drying sand and shingle
soils than does merlot, and (Angleterroir? post) this might account for the synergy between merlot and the smectite clays
of Petrus.
In 2005, Burgundy’s summer was
very dry, though spring rainfall levels had been plentiful. Through July and
August the difference between vine evapotranspiration and precipitation became
acute, reaching levels that would ordinarily impair vine metabolic function and
nutrient uptake (P at flowering; Mg/K/Ca between flowering and veraison). The vines
that were best able to cope with this drought-regime would have been those
that had access to a supplementary source of water. The proximity of limestone
aquifers, and their capacity to capillary feed moisture into the overlying soils
would have been hugely advantageous in the CdN's better Crus, whilst superficially
rooted vineyards planted on deeper soils may have much been less tolerant of the anomylous climatic conditions.
It will be interesting to follow the fortunes of the vintage, which when it came to market was highly acclaimed. It may well be that for the reasons outlined above, the wines turn out to far less consistent than was originally thought.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








