This is the latest from the vineyard AG sensor. It shows the
impact of the recent rain on soil moisture levels. We still need to calibrate it
against soil moisture availability, because it is one of the truisms of soil
hydrology that water capacity and availability are not the same. Late rainfall
is an issue for UK vineyards because it relieves hydric stress precisely at the
point when you need it to add impetus to ripening.
Wednesday, 26 September 2012
Tuesday, 25 September 2012
Three Vinetrail Loire Whites
“Pineau d’Aunis” is not “Pinot d’Aunis”. Homonyms ain't what they used to be. I no longer confuse “new” with “knew”, but in accepting Richard Kelley MW’s invitation to taste Pineau d’Aunis, I muddled-up the novel with the familiar. Pinot d’Aunis sounded much more interesting.
“No! Pineau. P-I-N-E-A-U. Red chenin; it’s blended with Arbois to make a Rosé…in Cheverny; and they make a red wine out of it near Jasnières: Coteaux du Vendômois”
As Richard spoke, the river I thought I knew spilled free of its mapped basin, adding tributaries and vineyards as it surged. I had always thought that Robin Yapp had done a meticulous Victorian job cataloguing and collecting the complete genus of Loire chenin, but Richard’s obsession seemed as boundless as the new river he was describing.
Pineau d’Aunis has the flavour and bitterness of chicory, I soon learnt; and not much “red” colour. It could easily be one of those wartime proxies; an ersatz “cabernet franc” to wash down the lard “butter” and margarine “chocolate”. One of the wines we tasted was bio, which seemed a pointless hardship for the producer as it was the worst of the lot. Everything had been tried, but nothing so far seemed to be working. Pineau d’Aunis is a hateful glass of wine; that’s really all there is to say.
Richard may not have identified the source of the Loire for me, but in Vendômois he had brought me to its nadir, the place where this giant vignoble finally bottoms-out. French wine production has a broad base, there is viticultural life below Muscadet and gros plant, it’s just we don’t very often get to taste it, unless you get lost south of Le Mans. Being at the foot of the pyramid is tough, but in France you either fit in or ship-out. If you find yourself at the bottom of life’s pile, La Répubique will normally find a way of aggrandising your useless job into a pensionable profession; whilst the reward for not planting pinot noir in the Vendômois was Appellation d’Origine Contrôlée status, granted in 2001. Authenticating the bad can sometimes accentuate the good.
“Travelling” through life facing backwards” is a Chinese maxim, but it might equally well apply to France, where “the past” and “tradition” always seem to be plonked down squarely in front of you, so it’s a relief to come across wines from ambitious growers “who are challenging conventions and perceptions”; which is how the Muscadet of Domaine de la Quilla was introduced to me. The wine underlined the fact that Muscadet and Chardonnay are genetic twins whose personalities occasionally overlap. A long lunch had left me feeling like I'd been shoved into my lounge suit, a snugness duplicated by the la Quilla, which packed a lot of wine into the glass. Tasted blind, I would have guessed Chablis; it was voluminous, and lacking in that abrasive sea-air tang that ordinarily singles Muscadet out.
The second wine I tried was Sauvignon de Tourraine “le Petiot” 2011, from Domaine Ricard. I’ve always drunk Sancerre and Pouilly-Fume, but as a single variety, sauvignon had to register success in the Southern Hemisphere before I began to appreciate wines from closer to home. On a rainy day “le Petiot” gave my mood a lift: a chlorophyll-loaded draught of spring that chased away the gloom. It had power, too, its character pressing out from within, as is the way with all the better wines from this latitude. Back in New Zealand, sauvignon’s simple pleasures are being increasingly overlooked, lost beneath the hubris of research and analysis; a postmodern wine blight, if you will. All these people troubling themselves with what I want, when all I really care about is having a choice. The same might be said for la Quilla’s wine too. Isn’t Muscadet supposed to be an austere wine that needs the support of local shellfish and the Vendéen sunshine to show at its best? Versatility comes at a cost, starting with a loss of identity.
The last of Vinetrail’s Loire whites was the Montlouis-sur-Loire “Premier Rendez-Vous” 2010, from Lise and Betrand Jousset. I had drunk this wine before, at L’Enclume, with their eight course tasting menu. L’Enclume’s food is consistently beautiful. Each plate is like a still life. There are elements of draughtsmanship in the presentation, neat rhomboids of fish and meat that you don’t really want to demolish. It is a treat for the senses, but perilous territory for wine. Jousset’s Montlouis was perfect; to the rich dishes it brought texture and a firm acidity, while its flavours of quince and barley didn’t overwhelm the Morecambe Bay cockles. If a course ever wanted for seasoning, there is a lick of saltiness from all the underlying limestone, though Simon Rogan’s food really needs no amendment.
I neglect the Loire, perhaps because my point of entry for most regions is through their red wines. Huge volumes of Loire cabernet franc sluice though Parisian wine bars, but I find the wines a little back-to-front, just like that Chinese maxim: the flavours I want in the background are in the foreground, and all those tight tannins can cause the wines to finish before they ever get started. Pineau d’Aunis did nothing to change my opinion of Loire reds, but I have decided to buy a TomTom, just in case I find myself lost near Vendômois, on the way to Montlouis-sur-Loire .
Saturday, 15 September 2012
The River Cottage Canteen, Axminster
We shouldn’t be surprised that “The
River Cottage Canteen” sounds a lot like the “The River Café Canteen”, the
latter is one of Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall’s almae matres (Eton and St Peter’s College, Oxford being the others),
though he left under a cloud after just eight months. Indicatively, eight
months in a restaurant is about the time it takes to go from dishwashing to
glass polishing, and these responsibilities might have hastened Hugh’s
downfall. Perhaps, like Narcissus, he just became too obsessed with his own
image isometrically projected onto the posh Riedel glassware, a big face on a
small bowl; and maybe in these moments of studied reflection he and his
employers simultaneously saw another future for Hugh, one that required him to leave
the River Café with immediate effect.
The River Café’s loss was Channel
4’s gain. There have been nine series of The
River Cottage, which in terms of broadcast hours and screen time puts Hugh right-up
there with the likes of Rodney and Del Boy. Better still, for Hugh, are all the
spin-offs that come from the series: a stack of books, two Canteens and a
cookery school. Nobody seriously wanted to follow the Trotters into Nelson
Mandela House, but we all want a piece of Hugh and his living, breathing larder.
Just like one of those battery hens that Hugh is always trying to save, The River Cottage just keeps on laying.
The success of the BBC’s Pot Black was put down to the advent of colour
TV, when the snooker balls finally broke-free from all the black and white
camouflage. Likewise, the nine series of The
River Cottage have coincided with the arrival of bigger, surround-sound versions
of the sitting-room TV. Over nine years, Hugh’s image has become engorged by
plasma, his veg impossibly green, and
the instruction to boycott the value-aisles sounds like a personalised message
to me and our dog, Roly. Because The River
Cottage isn’t just family viewing with the foul-mouthed gags of the celebrity
guests edited out along with the Dorset rain and fog: as with all the
campaigning, it crosses the species divide.
My wife’s interest in River
Cottage isn’t the same as the dog’s and mine. She loves the japes, the guests,
the “vintage” affectation, and the forager
camping it up in the hedgerows. She seemed saddened by Hugh’s recent haircut;
maybe she just wanted to run her hands through those draping curls that in HD resembled
a pair of dagged spaniels’ ears. If Hugh
wanted someone for Elope to River Cottage
she would be there with Roly, who seems fixated by the story of the piglets; after
hours of viewing and repeats his feeble dog mind has pieced together a chronology
of events that runs like a children’s rhyme, weeners-pigman-knackerman-pork. Together, on the sofa, as man and
dog, we have become obsessed with the crisp, marmaladey rinds of “Spice” and “Baby”
that appear from Hugh’s antique Aga; the mouth-watering golden sunset of fat at
the end of the hour-long River Cottage day.
The Axminster Canteen lies on the
East Devon border, but most importantly it provided me with an opportunity to
play the top predator at the head of River Cottage’s televised food chain. John
Updike, once asked the question “Why does Nature demand so much fucking?” and
after nine series of The River Cottage
and the incessant comings and goings of the
pigman and the slaughterman I
have realised that it’s not Nature but people like me who are driving this crazed
treadmill of bestial sex and mortality. From the very start, Hugh may have been
developing a well-reasoned argument for improving animal welfare, but from my
side of the television screen, the amber vision of all that crackling had begun
to possess me. Axminster was destined to be an epic encounter between me and
the three little pigs. Waiting at the table, I conjured-up the movements of the
slaughterman, urging him through the
gates of River Cottage, and then parking him up, over by the sty.
Endlessly repeated episodes of The River Cottage had brought me to this
point. I looked around the restaurant: there was no Hugh, and no sign of the
Chef whose whiskers seem forever stuck in that scratchy stage. Perhaps they
were at Tesco, or the new Dorchester Poundland; another campaign, with Hugh foisting
himself like the Ancient Mariner on Axminster’s shoppers as they sleepwalked
their way towards the brutalised BOGOF carcasses. The shame was that if they
had been at the Canteen, then surely they wouldn’t have allowed my food to come
out as it did. Long roasting should bring a sepia tint to a haunch, but this pig’s
fat had been braised into a mottled, pale ghost of my expectations; whilst the veg appeared as blanched and colourless
as the snooker balls on those old black and white TVs.
I suspect the latest series of The River Cottage will be much like the
old one. When I think of West Dorset now, I don’t think of Hugh’s husbandry, or
the personable forager; instead, I think
of deep space, and whorls of stars spiralling towards an abysmal fate. Just as
black holes drag everything into themselves, distorting time and space, so The River Cottage sucks everything in,
before filtering and spitting it out the other side. I feel like I’m being fed something Hugh has
already chewed-over in attempt to make it seem more palatable, like baby food,
only it tastes like that pulped gruel they served me at Axminster. Daft
professions, old utensils, the Citroen
2CV, yurts, jam-making, things out of their time and place, all mashed
together, whilst the world beyond of Vauxhalls, bad jobs and Hugh’s wife seems
strangely absent.
If I’m down on Hugh it’s because
I was disappointed with his food, yet at home I am the only dissenter. My wife,
daughters and dog still enjoy the show, and a happy family is as important to
me as happy pigs and chickens are to Hugh. After nine years the wheels had come
off the Trotters' Reliant Robin, yet the River Cottage keeps on rolling along. Being
good at something requires dedication. Hugh spent eight months trying to be a chef,
and eight years making TV programmes. The continuing popularity and re-commissioning
of his show underlines the fact he is rather good at the latter. Just make sure
you don’t confuse the River Cottage
Canteen with the fabulous River Café
Canteen, or think Hugh is a great chef, because he isn’t.
Friday, 31 August 2012
The Gurnard's Head, Zennor
Among the more elaborate theories
of the Hungarian psychoanalyst Sandor Ferenczi, is the idea of Thalassal Trend, the desire to return to
a sea-state, manifested through dreams of becoming a fish. I
invariably forget my dreams, but as a Pisces I’m jealous of anybody who
nightly shoals and spawns with a thousand like-minded neurotics while I snore
and dribble my way into the void.
If Ferenczi was still with us, I am sure he could convince me in a completely plausible
way that I, too, harbour a fantasy of returning to a sea-state. Who knows, he
might even get me into the water. As a child the best journeys always ended in
the sea, where now they finish at the beach or, better still, a cliff. I want
the scent of tide; the percussive smash and clawing of waves; the luminosity - but
I also want to be dry. Dry and warm. Nowadays, the sea must seduce me from a
distance.
A love of the ocean is an affair
of the heart and mind, and nowhere is this desire better fulfilled than at the
Gurnard’s Head Hotel. The Cornish roads whittle down to single tracks the
moment you cross the county-line, and past St Ives, these meandering lanes,
like Swinburne’s weariest river, eventually “wind somewhere safe to sea”. A mile west of Zennor and you come to the
Hotel, and beyond that, to the north, the Gurnard’s Head proper, an obstinate lava
promontory, humped leviathan-like within the swell.
Painted across the Hotel’s roof
in big letters is THE GURNARD’S HEAD; - a sign would blow over, or be ripped
away by gales. The weather forecast for Zennor is The Shipping Forecast. Few trees grow here, and there’s a year-round
khaki scorch to the grass. The first time I stayed it hailed on me in the car
park, but when I visited this June the platinum sun rolled uninterrupted through
the blue space of day.
Head Chef, Bruce Rennie, trained
with Martin Wishart in Edinburgh, but his food is altogether more primal. There
is no rendering of the familiar into novel, unrecognisable forms; instead, Bruce
has perfected the more important skills of seasoning and cooking à point. Calves liver and lamb
shank were nourishing and full of flavour, and if I hadn’t been worried about
appearing greedy I would have immediately re-ordered Dover Sole served with
capers and fennel.
The wine list is an affirmation of
proprietor Charles Inkin’s taste. The worst wine lists are those that lamely
offer you the world in the hope that you will see something you’ll recognise;
the best scream “This is what we like, and you will like it too!” I had my first taste of Fichet’s brilliant Hautes-Côtes
de Beaune at the Gurnard’s, and was blind tasted on an interesting Slovenian
wine that I couldn’t remember the name of the next morning. The red wines are also strung together by
Charles’ passion, rather than by region or country. Burgundy and Bordeaux seem
to become deeper, darker versions of themselves when served on these Cornish cliff
tops, and the Ridge Monte Bello I opened one night appeared to add extra muscle mass to its already well-developed form.
In a few weeks I will get down to
the Gurnard’s Head again, just in time for the equinoctial gales. If Cornwall is
a kingdom, then Zennor is a fiefdom within it. I haven’t been anywhere else
that makes this Island feel so much like an island. I will arrive for lunch,
but lowering skies or a change in the tide has a habit of turning lunch into
dinner there. I shall, as the Gurnard's Head brochure advises, “Eat, drink, sleep”,
and maybe, just this once, dream briny, monocular, fishy thoughts.
Tuesday, 28 August 2012
Late August - but looks like mid-summer
An illusion of bounty as veraison begins at Tixover in 2012. This is Acolon which this year has put up a spirited fight against the weather. The soil is argilo-calcaireous-clay/limestone-but the mix sticks to gravelly French proportions.
The removal of the leaves adjacent to the 2nd cluster and the node immediately above creates a window for the slanting rays of the sun. We pull leaves at fruit set, when intrabunch shading is minimal. Shoots are topped at 15 nodes, so the removal of these two primaries should be compensated for by the remaining leaves and the growth of laterals.
Monday, 27 August 2012
Vine Density
It can get pretty crowded in the
vineyards of France. Within Champagne and Burgundy vine densities of around 10000
plants per hectare are normal, but more congested planting is not exceptional. Head
south, towards the Midi, and viticulture becomes more spacious: fewer vines, less
leaves and shoots, and much more visible earth.
When I first consulted someone about planting densities for Tixover, the
advice was “a tractor width plus a metre x 1.5 metre”; which worked out to 2000
plants per hectare for a 70hp machine. From somebody that had been in the UK
business for a considerable time, this was sound practical advice; Nature is
hard to dominate without mechanical assistance, and bare soil favours a rapid return
to the full diversity of the indigenous flora rather than the unchallenged success
of an invasive monoculture. Still, hoeing is hoeing, and the move from man to
horses and tractors as the means of weed suppression, if anything, lowered vine
densities within Burgundy and Champagne. For the monks of the Abbaye, the hoe
must have been an instrument of self-flagellation.
There is an economic argument for
high vine densities: more vines = more fruit, and a better return per hectare.
In 2004, Champagne produced 140hl/ha. A small and early harvest in 2003 led to
a proliferation in bud numbers and vine reserves, and this potential was fully
realised in the near perfect flowering conditions of 2004. The subsequent
harvest yielded both quality and quantity.
Another perspective on vine
density is offered by Alain Carbonneau of Bordeaux University. In cool climates
– Northern France, UK, Germany – Carbonneau suggests that shoot length needs to
be a minimum of 80% of row width, in order that the vines are put under
conditions that favour the induction of hydric stress. Carbonneau’s thesis is
that the water capacity of a vineyard soil is depleted more rapidly if the
total exposed leaf area of the overlying vineyard is maximised. This
prescription works itself out into some interesting ratios. Burgundy’s 1m x 1m
planting with a 20cm fruiting wire and shoot topping at 80cm perfectly
satisfies Carbonneau’s conditions; whilst a row width of 1.6m demands a shoot
length of 1.3m. Worryingly, the recommended tractor-friendly row dimension of 3m
would require unworkable 2.4m long shoots to achieve similarly advantageous proportions.
What is common to Bordeaux,
Burgundy and Champagne is that the peak in seasonal water deficits coincides
with veraison. At some point between late July and early August, the vines divert
their resources away from vegetative growth and towards fruit ripening. On the
Cote de Nuits, crop evapotranspiration for the 4 week period that has veraison
at its centre averages 130mm, with precipitation only replacing 60mm of this
loss. Assuming that the vines' access to soil moisture is limited (arguably the
defining characteristic of Burgundy’s finest appellations) then vine and berry
growth will be constrained, and ripening accelerated. Just how these benefits
are conferred on the bunches is still open for discussion. Richard Smart sees the
advantages of water deficits deriving indirectly from reduced vigour and the
concomitant improvement of the light environment in and around the clusters;
whilst Mark Matthews and Stefano Poni posit a more direct link between
advantageous gene expression and soil drying. Neither view precludes the other,
but which side of the argument you favour has consequences as to how you spend
your time in the vineyard. Those who follow
Smart believe leaf removal, green pruning and vine architecture can
substitute for terroir, whereas subscribers to the Matthews' dictum, “It’s the
journey and not the destination that matters” will spend their time seeking out
pedological conditions that optimise vine stress.
It may well be that in the UK's
relatively damp, cool and sunless climate we have to embrace both strategies, and view the
theories and prescriptions of Smart and Matthews as being in some sense simultaneous,
rather than conflicting. On average, Burgundy picks Pinot Noir at 940GDD after
budburst, and Champagne 870GDD. Nowadays, these summations are achieved in
mid-September, but under the UKs maritime climatic regime these values are
reached (if at all) in October, under lowering skies, downward spiralling
temperatures and the constant threat of rain.
The skewed pattern in phenology between France’s northern appellations and
the vineyards of Southern England is entrenched by flowering. Mid-floraison in
Champagne and Burgundy occurs 2-3 weeks ahead of the most precocious English
vineyards, which pushes veraison on this side of the Channel into late August
and early September, when crop evapotranspiration and precipitation are often equivalent,
and thus, free of hydric stress.
One anxiety voiced against close
planting is that it increases the shading of one canopy by another. Logically,
more distant rows will intercept more of the early morning and late evening sun
than rows of the same height planted closer together. The idea has appeal, but as
the illustration below shows (Courtesy of Cornell University) the gains from
planting wider are marginal, and almost certainly counterproductive, as vigour and
canopy shading will tend to increase at lower vine densities.
The other multiple used to calculate
vine density is within row spacing. As was the case with row width, the higher vineyards
push into the eaves of the l’Hexagone,
the tighter the spacing between the vines becomes. At Tixover, our widest
spacing is 1.2 metres, and our narrowest 0.6 metres. The wider spacing reflects
the advice we were given when we first planted the site, but we have since
discovered that our vines are only comfortable pushing 5-6 shoots of even
vigour. To avoid shoot congestion and
acrotony along the fruiting canes we decided to spur prune the vines.
The above choices have given us
two vine densities: the 0.6mx1.7m= 9700 vines per/ha; and the 1.2mx1.7m= 4800
vines per/ha. All vines have 1.3m, 15 node shoots, which gets us close to the
ratio of shoot length to row width suggested by Carbonneau. The canopy density
has been excellent in both vineyards, though we do remove two leaves on every
shoot at fruit set - those immediately adjacent to and above the second cluster
– to improve light exposure during the pre-veraison period when intra-bunch
shading is minimal.
As with any field-based trial,
the confounding variable is often the weather. Somewhere between May and July of
this year, we lost nearly a month’s worth of an already short growing season,
and I am doubtful that the crop will ever reach maturity. Interestingly, vigour
this year has shown no increase despite the rainfall, and berry size at
lag-phase is small. This can be interpreted in several ways, but I suspect root
growth was suppressed by soil saturation through the spring, and the subsequent
dry and warm weather we have experienced since fruit set has inducted some
stress into the vines. Unfortunately, the two AG moisture probes we have in the
ground have also become victims of the weather, so we will have to wait until
next year to get good data on fluctuations in soil moisture availability and capacity.
Friday, 17 August 2012
Angleterroir?
Superficially, our soil looks like some of the better bits of the Côte
de Nuits. The soil is composed of clay (25%), limestone gravel (25%), silt
(30%), and sand (20%). In the shallower parts of Grand Cru Romanée St Vivant
you hit Bajocian bedrock at a depth of 30cm, and it’s the same for Tixover.
Shuffling around on your haunches you might imagine yourself to be in Vosne.
The first time I tested our soil, I also submitted samples gathered from across
the Côte de Nuits. The results for Romanée-Conti confirmed it as “a good
agricultural soil”, with macronutrients falling within the 2-3 range of
standard farming indices; endorsing its potential as a wheat field should the
wine business ever go to pot. The ratio of K:Mg in Le Chambertin and Clos de la
Roche was skewed towards potassium, and the pH for all three sites was between
7.8 and 8.3. The results for the Tixover sample closely resembled those of the
Grands Crus. All four had excessive calcium levels.
The second soil test was analysed in France. It introduced me to new
concepts like cation exchange capacity
(CEC), and base-saturation. Our soil
was high in nitrogen and calcium, but weak in iron and magnesium. The ratio
between calcium and magnesium influences soil structure, and soils that are
base-saturated with calcium tend to be more porous than soils dominated by
magnesium. A high Ca/Mg ratio generally facilitates water movements within the
soil - up, down and sideways.
The most recent test, conducted by Albrecht Agriculture, was also the
most thorough, and the results showed worrying discrepancies from the previous
two analyses. Iron was recorded at a critically low level, and the CEC was
measured at 30meq, which is high for a soil that is only 25% clay. The “clay
and colloidal matter” bound calcium and magnesium ions in the ratio of 40:1.
Our soil, Albrecht warned us, was like a sieve. We needed to add magnesium,
lots of magnesium. But at least we were in good company: the three Grands Crus
soils were similarly biased in favour of calcium base-saturation.
Confusingly, iron levels were only measured at 1ppm by the Albrecht
people, but at 15ppm by the lab in Montpellier. We haven’t seen signs of
chlorosis in the vines, so experience suggests the French analysis is the more
accurate of the two. Moreover, despite identifying the chronically deficient
iron levels, the Albrecht analysis didn’t propose any amendments other than the
magnesium. Critics of scientific methodology warn about theory laden data, and
the Albrecht obsession with the calcium:magnesium ratio may explain why in this
instance they missed the low iron count.
CEC is a measure of the nutrient holding capacity of the soil, and
relates principally to the number of internal and external bonding sites within
the sample’s clay and colloidal fraction. The meq measurement was elevated in our sample by the mix of clays.
Smectite, a volcanic mineral, was incorporated into our clay as it sedimented
out, and its inclusion has significantly changed the soils properties. For
Agronomist, Claude Bourguignon, smectite/montmorillonite clays, with their
large internal surface areas, are particularly advantageous for red wine
production. Just why these clays are so interesting to M. Bourguignon is worth consideration.
According to Bourguignon, the soils of Petrus together with most of
Vosne’s Grands Crus (Romanée-Conti may be the exception) are luxuriously
endowed with smectite. By contrast, the illite-kalolinite clays of the white
Grands Crus have much smaller surface areas, and therefore their capacity to
hold and exchange nutrients is considerably lower. Montmorillonite clays are
also distinguishable from other clays by the extent to which they expand when
wetted. Modest water deficits are seen as advantageous in wine production as
they accelerate ripening and generally improve the quality and quantity of
extractable solids from the skins, so a clay that absorbs and holds onto
copious amounts of water would seem anomalous to the requirements of premium
grape production. Montmorillonite clays do have a trick, however. Strong root
growth and function require a good level of root oxygenation. The expansion of montmorillonite
clays can be so dramatic that root growth and function become impaired.
Moreover, the permeability of the clays can decrease due to sealing at their surfaces
after wetting. Thus soils may look wet, puddled even, but this moisture is not
necessarily available to the roots; a case of water, water everywhere and not a
drop to drink. And just as they expand when wetted, so montmorillonite clays
shrink when dried. A sustained period of drought will open up capillaries
within the soil which then become exploited by the vines’ constantly
regenerating mesh of short-lived rootlets. Taking into account the close
connection between vacillations in clay particle size and Bordeaux’s changeable
seasons, it is possible to model a shallow, smectite-rich soil in which the
availability of moisture to the vine roots is almost continually held at
deficit levels;- a terroir very much like that of Petrus, in fact.
Beneath the thin clay loams of Vosne’s Grands Crus is limestone. The
ability of vine roots to populate hard rock is limited, but this fact hasn’t
stopped commentators from positing this hidden union as the very foundation of
terroir. However, a more probable explanation of limestone’s advantage to
viticulture is revealed by a consideration of its physical properties. Limestone
can hold large volumes of water, but, as was discussed in the context of clays,
we must be careful not to confuse capacity with availability. Movement of water through soils is
multidirectional, and limestone can irrigate the clays resting upon it through
capillary action. The extent to which the capillaries are opened will in turn
depend upon the relative expansion of the clays and the degree to which calcium
base-saturation has flocculated these, the most minuscule of soil particles,
into larger agglomerations. In other words, the limestone’s ability to function
as an aquifer is itself dependent upon the structure of the overlying soil. As was
the case with Petrus above, we can imagine a possible balance between local
effects whose equilibrium point sustains the vines at a slight and ultimately
advantageous level of water deficit.
On the Côte de Nuits the mercurial temperament of Pinot Noir brings
colour and texture to the bland realms of geology and pedology. In her
excellent articles on “Calcium in Viticulture”, Valerie Saxton talks of
“terroir ridden France”, and Burgundy can seem like yet another scion of the Republic’s
obsession with taxonomy and hierarchy. So completely pixelated has the map of
Cote d’Or’s vineyards become, that it’s now virtually impossible for outsiders
to see the whole picture. Twenty
years ago, many New World growers censured the Côte d’Or. It just didn’t make
sense: Grands Crus a stone’s throw from modest village vineyards; and Clos
Vougeot, the oversized Circus Maximus
at the centre of this antiquated world, just seemed to lump together everything
that the rest of the classification had painstakingly tried to keep apart.
There are historical precedents for Burgundy’s sub-divisions, but the
acute sensitivity of Pinot Noir coupled to the equally acute sensibilities of
those that tend to it is the more remarkable story of this segregation. One way
of classifying grape varieties is through their differing responses to water
deficits. Anisohydric vines are said
to be drought tolerant, whilst isohydric
varieties are drought avoiding. The divide is not clear-cut, and relates to the
strength of response different varieties show towards hormonal signalling
(abscisic acid) from the drying roots. The stomata of isohydric varieties
progressively close, rationing water uptake and loss, whilst anisohydric
varieties maintain stomatal turgor, such that gas exchange, water uptake and
carbon gain are unimpeded. Isohydric vines are “pessimistic” and anisohydric
vines “optimistic”, inasmuch as the latter carry on as if they expect it to
rain again tomorrow.
Some varieties seem capable of both responses, but in extremis, Pinot Noir is anisohydric, and Grenache Noir
isohydric. Lavish water use, as
exemplified by Pinot Noir, brings with it a vulnerability to sustained drought.
Pinot Noir, by rapidly depleting soil moisture can accelerate itself towards conditions
under which its own metabolic processes become compromised, just like the man
who saws-furiously at the branch he’s resting on. Without the self-buffering
responses of isohydric varieties, Pinot Noir’s own water status is so immediately bound to the vicissitudes
of soil moisture that it takes, in unirrigated Burgundy, a very special mix of
extraneous pedological factors to consistently produce high quality grapes,
i.e. those that are the result of sustained, but not impairing water deficits.
Vosne’s Grands Crus are, indeed, exceptional.
Claude Bourguignon caused me to depart from thoughts of my own soil
analyses and on-going struggle to get consistent data. There have been reasons for optimism in most
of the results, and I don’t doubt the fact that if Tixover’s three blocks of
brashy soil were panelled into Morey or Chambolle you wouldn’t see the joins,
but it’s ridiculous to start talking about terroir, particularly when we seem
to have spent the last few years acquainting ourselves with a whole load of
Nature’s disadvantages. I remember with incredulity, a vineyard owner in Long
Island exploiting the argument that Bordeaux’s Crus were the finest in the World,
and that Bordeaux’s vineyard were flat, and as his vineyards were flat, too, it
followed that his wines were rivals to the Médoc.
As said, there was a time when the majority of New World growers rejected
terroir, portraying it as either a perspicacious piece of marketing, or homey make-believe.
But somewhere along the track these protagonists either gave-up on this line of
attack or lost the argument, because producers in Chile, New Zealand and
Mendoza nowadays reel-off neat invocations about the contingency of their own
vineyard work that wouldn’t sound out of place in Vosne. Wine now seems so exclusively
“made in the vineyard”, it’s hard to know if there is anything left for
winemakers to do. In the New World, terroir has gone from being nowhere to
being everywhere.
The ubiquity of terroir is problematic.
I take from the late Peter Sichel’s remark that only a fraction of
Bordeaux’s vineyards genuinely exhibit terroir-characteristics, that terroir is
a title bestowed like an honour or a peerage, rather than a democratic entitlement
to which anyone with a vine growing up a wall has an equal claim. Accordingly, Richebourg
and Petrus are the exemplars of terroir, the foundations and acmes of a system
in which exceptionality and scarcity are paradigmatic. In this context, the work of Claude Bourguignon,
Gerard Seguin and Cornelius van Leeuwen is so pertinent because they are trying,
in different ways, to cleave some scientific traction into our understanding of
a much abused term. For those who crave more metaphysical accounts of grape
quality, who will never be moved by terms like “vine water status” or “point
quadrant analysis”, there is always Nicolas Joly. But this is to miss the
point. When physicists revealed diamonds’ atomic structure they didn’t stop them
from being a girl’s best friend.
I do share Peter Sichel’s instinct for parsimony, not least because the
over-extension of any term, terroir included, eventually runs the risk of draining
all significance from it. The meaning of words changes over time, and despite
van Leeuwen’s attempts to give terroir intellectual rigour, I feel sure that
the term’s appropriators will win out. “Sense of place” will read like a
postcode.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






